Proudly serving Atlanta and the surrounding communities

How To Choose a Water Heater: 12 Factors to Consider For Your Best Options

How To Choose a Water Heater: 12 Factors to Consider

Before buying a hot water heater, there are several important factors to consider to ensure you choose the right unit for your home:

  1. Type of Water Heater
  2. Fuel Type
  3. Capacity
  4. Energy Efficiency
  5. Cost
  6. Space and Location
  7. Lifespan
  8. Warranty
  9. Maintenance
  10. Local Codes and Permits
  11. Recovery Rate (for Tank Water Heaters)
  12. Smart Features

Type of Water Heater

  • Tank Water Heater: Stores hot water in a large tank, available in gas or electric models. These are typically more affordable upfront but less energy-efficient than tankless models.
  • Tankless Water Heater: Heats water on demand, so you never run out. They are more energy-efficient and take up less space, but they come with a higher initial cost.
  • Heat Pump Water Heater: Uses heat from the air or ground to heat the water, making them very energy-efficient, but they are also more expensive upfront.
  • Solar Water Heater: Uses energy from the sun to heat water, ideal for eco-friendly homes but can be expensive and may need a backup system in less sunny regions.

Fuel Type

  • Electric: Easier to install and generally less expensive upfront but may have higher operational costs depending on electricity rates.
  • Gas: Often more energy-efficient and cheaper to operate than electric, but they require a gas line and proper venting.
  • Propane: Similar to gas heaters, but you’ll need access to a propane supply.
  • Solar or Hybrid: Highly energy-efficient but come with higher upfront costs.

Capacity

  • Tank Water Heaters: Choose a tank size based on your household size and hot water usage. For example, a 40-50 gallon tank is typically enough for a family of 4.
  • Tankless Water Heaters: These are sized based on flow rate (gallons per minute, GPM) and temperature rise. Ensure the unit can handle the simultaneous demand of your household (e.g., running a shower and dishwasher at the same time).

Energy Efficiency

  • Look for the Energy Factor (EF) or Uniform Energy Factor (UEF) ratings, which indicate how efficiently the water heater converts energy into hot water. Higher numbers mean greater efficiency.
  • Energy Star-rated models are a good choice for reducing energy consumption and lowering utility bills.

Cost

  • Consider both the initial cost of the unit and the long-term operating costs. While tankless and energy-efficient models are more expensive upfront, they can save money in the long run through reduced energy use.
  • Don’t forget to factor in installation costs, which can vary depending on the complexity of the installation and whether you’re switching between fuel types.

Space and Location

  • Ensure the water heater will fit in the intended space. Tankless water heaters are compact and can be installed in small spaces, whereas tank heaters require more room.
  • Consider ventilation requirements if choosing a gas-powered unit.

Lifespan

  • Tank water heaters typically last 8-12 years
  • Tankless models can last up to 20 years. A longer lifespan may justify a higher initial cost.

Warranty

  • Check the manufacturer’s warranty for both the unit and its parts. Longer warranties typically indicate a more durable and reliable product.

Maintenance

  • Some types of water heaters, like tank models, need regular maintenance, such as flushing the tank to remove sediment. Tankless heaters also need periodic descaling if you have hard water.

Local Codes and Permits

  • Make sure your new water heater complies with local building codes. You may also need permits for installation, especially for gas and solar water heaters.

Recovery Rate (for Tank Water Heaters)

  • The recovery rate for tank water heaters measures how quickly the heater can reheat water after it has been depleted. A higher recovery rate is better for larger families who use a lot of hot water.

Smart Features

  • Some modern water heaters come with smart controls that allow you to monitor and control the water heater via a smartphone app, helping you adjust temperatures and maximize energy savings.

By considering these factors, you can select the best hot water heater that fits your household’s needs, budget, and energy goals.

From traditional gas and electric water heaters to modern tankless and high-efficiency models, we’ll help you choose and install the perfect system for your home. At Plumbing Express we offer the latest Rinnai® tankless water heater technology and the most reliable Rheem® tank water heaters.

Plumbing Express

Plumbing Express 3050 Presidential Dr #202, Atlanta, GA 30340

What Atlanta Homeowners Say About Plumbing Express

Our 4.9-star rating comes from 2,000+ Google reviews written by real homeowners across Metro Atlanta. Here is what a few of them had to say.

Read more reviews on Google or visit our customer reviews page to see why Atlanta homeowners choose Plumbing Express.

google
Jatara Ross
February 11, 2026

Service couldn’t be completed due to needing a new system. We appreciate the very informative visit as well as insight that could help after a new unit install.

google
Bob Gallup
February 6, 2026

Plumbing Express was great. I had a failed sump pump that had partially overflowed into the basement. Nasty. Josh was the tech that did the work. He was efficient, neat and courteous. I will use Plumbing Express if I have any other plumbing needs and I will recommend them to my family and friends.

google
Jim Kilburn
February 6, 2026

He was great

google
Dwayne Cannon
February 6, 2026

The technician was very knowledgeable and professional. I believe they did a very good job.

google
Freda Iaizzi
February 6, 2026

Ron was our second plumber from this company. The first plumber came, examined pipes and said he found no leak, even though we had experiences a large amount of water leaking from the ceiling in the finished basement. Several days later we had another leak-same area but less water the second time. Ron came in, listened to our frustration and did a more thorough inspection of the pipes and identified the problem. He was very personable and professional. On his third visit, we had several replacement pipes installed and are without leaks again. Our frustration, with the situation, was my son had used your company to replace pipes when he purchased the home and founding out not all the pipes were included with that process.

google
Shaleypoley rocks
February 6, 2026

They always do a great job

google
KB Johnson
February 6, 2026

Tim arrived on time and was very professional. He took his time to explain the problem and the process it would take fix the water line.

google
Jay Betts
February 5, 2026

Called Plumbing Express as tankless hot water not operating. Their website states "Get Free Plumbing Quote ". When service man showed up an looked at unit he said there would be a $207 charge to look into unit in order to give me a quote to fix unit. Due to not having hot water and time required to get another company to address the problem I agreed to pay $207 for quote. After looking in unit I was told he would not be able to fix due to age of unit and parts not available. I think he should have said parts not available when seeing model number on front of unit and I would not have wasted $207.

google
Kim Isaacs
February 5, 2026

Outstanding customer service, we will definitely be using them in the future for any plumbing needs. Can’t thank them enough!

google
Ray Reynolds
February 4, 2026

Extremely knowledgeable and very helpful. The team was excellent. The job was completed in 1 day with a great team. Very expressive.

google
Elizabeth Miller
February 3, 2026

Daniel Perez was great in coming out to check the problem I had with a water leak from my air conditioner line. His recommendation was correct.

google
Nicholas Stodd
February 2, 2026

Great and informative service while I was in a bind without a functioning water heater.

google
Sharron Stephens
February 2, 2026

Plumbing Express is my go-to plumbing support team. They have fair pricing, well-vetted technicians, and a truly exceptional scheduling system. Rod, my technician, was the best. He quickly assessed the problem and gave a fair estimate, working hard to keep to the schedule. He even brought Josh along on the day of service, and the two of them worked well together. They addressed the bathtub drain repair with expertise and caused the least sheetrock damage. It was difficult to replace the broken pipe and get to the upstairs drain, but together they made it a success.

google
On Cue
January 30, 2026

Daniel did a great job and was very professional during his service call last week!

google
Victoria Tucker Limon
January 29, 2026

Rod and Josh did an awesome job taking care of my clogged sinks. Knowledgable, professional and great to work with - I really appreciated their help today and would highly recommend them and Plumbing Express!

google
william VAUGHN
January 29, 2026

Daniel was excellent. The work he did was simply superb. I highly recommend your company and hopefully Daniel will get more and more work

google
Christian Landon
January 29, 2026

Dylan from Plumbing Express came over and replaced our garbage disposal for us. It was older, had a massive leak, and needed to be replaced. He did a great job and was in and out in about 30 minutes! I also asked him to check out a potential leak I had been hearing in my ceiling. He used a thermal camera to investigate and was very honest and upfront about what he found. Rather than immediately cutting into the drywall to confirm something uncertain, he explained that the sound could simply be pipes expanding and that opening the wall might be unnecessary. He recommended monitoring the area and waiting to see if a wet spot appears, which would clearly indicate an actual leak. I really appreciated that he didn’t try to upsell or push unnecessary work. Overall, great service and a great guy. They will definitely be our go-to plumbing service from now on.

google
Mitchell Klasky
January 28, 2026

Tim was fast and explained options clearly

google
Jo-Ann Caster
January 27, 2026

Once again we had some problems under our kitchen sink so we called Plumbing Express who were able to get us on their schedule pretty quickly after these storms Tim Robinson came out to do the job. Tim has been to our house for a number of different plumbing problems. He is personable & professional. As usual he did a great job even though this particular problem turned out to be far more difficult than anyone had expected. As frustrating as it was, Tim worked through it until he finished the job. We can't thank him enough.

google
Robin R
January 27, 2026

Anthony was very competent, professional and friendly. He answered all my questions throughly. Highly recommend!